Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Five Premiers Press Carney to Withdraw Legal Bid to Curb Notwithstanding Clause

The joint protest casts Ottawa’s Bill 21 filing at the Supreme Court as a threat to provincial sovereignty.

Overview

  • Premiers of Ontario, Quebec, Alberta, Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia sent a letter Tuesday urging the federal government to retract its Supreme Court submission.
  • Ottawa’s filing in the Bill 21 appeal asks the court to let judges declare Charter violations even when Section 33 is invoked and to create review for prolonged or repeated use.
  • The federal argument says the clause’s temporary character cannot be used to cause an irreparable impairment of rights and that courts must retain jurisdiction to assess limits.
  • Quebec’s 2019 secularism law is the test case before the Supreme Court, with most factums filed and a hearing date not yet set.
  • Conservative leaders denounced Ottawa’s position as undermining provincial sovereignty and national unity, with Ontario’s Doug Ford calling it the prime minister’s worst decision.