Particle.news

Federal Judge Rules Hermon School Board Violated Church’s Rights

Judge Lance Walker found board members probed the church’s views on same-sex marriage and abortion, showing improper motive that made the denial unlawful under the First Amendment and Maine law.

Overview

  • The court’s Friday ruling declared that the Hermon School Board violated The Pines Church’s rights by denying a year-long lease for Sunday services because the rejection was driven by hostility to the church’s religious viewpoint.
  • Judge Lance Walker wrote that at least three of five board members acted with what he called a “bad motive” and singled out intrusive questioning of the pastor about same-sex marriage and abortion as evidence of viewpoint discrimination.
  • The Pines Church sued Hermon school officials in May 2023 after outgrowing a movie theater and seeking a fixed one-year lease at Hermon High School, a request the board declined while offering a month-to-month arrangement.
  • The court ordered a declaratory judgment that the denial violated both the U.S. Constitution and Maine’s public accommodations law and awarded nominal damages, and the church’s lawyers said the ruling exposed pretextual reasons used by the board.
  • The decision reaffirms that when public schools open facilities to community groups they must treat religious organizations neutrally, a point that could prompt districts to change how they vet or approve long-term rentals and how they record board deliberations.