Particle.news

Federal Judge Blocks Senate Tender for iPhones and Mobile Services

The ruling pauses contract signing to allow review of whether Apple‑specific specs and bidder rules illegally favor one brand under procurement law

Overview

  • A preliminary injunction by Judge Arthur Pinheiro Chaves from the 18th Federal Civil Court halted the Senate’s Pregão Eletrônico 290/2026 and barred homologation, adjudication, signing or execution of the contract.
  • The judge flagged explicit references to iPhone Pro models, demands for iOS 26, A19 Pro processors and 512 GB storage, and a clause forcing high‑end replacements after 24 months as possible violations of the law that forbids buying goods of quality above what is needed.
  • The court found the tender’s requirement that bidders show prior Apple‑comodato experience and its single‑lot structure could restrict competition by blocking firms that can supply Android devices from bidding on the full contract.
  • The ruling ordered the Senate to deliver the full administrative file within days, gave defendants five days to prove compliance under a R$50,000 daily fine, and called for MPF oversight and TCU notification while the case proceeds.
  • The procurement would supply 425 devices on a 48‑month comodato with an initial estimate of R$6.04 million and a lower Claro bid near R$4.95 million and the suspension leaves questions about legal compliance, economicity and how the Senate will justify its technical needs.