Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Federal Constitutional Court to Hear IHC Judges’ Appeal as Petitioners Contest Its Jurisdiction

The dispute tests whether Parliament could reshape appellate routes through the 27th Amendment.

Overview

  • The FCC has listed a six-judge bench led by Chief Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan to take up the IHC judges’ intra-court appeal on November 24 at 11:30am.
  • The five IHC judges filed a miscellaneous application asking the FCC to return their appeal to the Supreme Court, arguing it was brought under Section 5 of the Supreme Court (Practice and Procedure) Act, 2023 rather than Articles 175E or 175F.
  • The application contends a court created by the 27th Amendment cannot adjudicate the amendment’s validity and frames the transfer of their appeal as inconsistent with judicial independence and separation of powers.
  • The appeal follows a June 19 Supreme Court majority ruling that upheld the February transfers of three judges to the IHC, a move that reshaped the court’s seniority list and spurred the challenge.
  • The FCC has also constituted a five-member larger bench led by Justice Aamer Farooq to hear PTI’s election-rigging petition on November 25, as the new court rolls out operations including an official website and a winter recess from Dec 22 to Jan 4.