Overview
- The Federal Constitutional Court, which announced its reserved short order on Thursday, set aside the Sindh High Court and Peshawar High Court rulings and declared the provincial charging provisions unconstitutional.
- Chief Justice Amin authored a detailed 60‑page judgment that said the right inquiry is the statutory event that triggers the charge and the levy’s true operation rather than its label as an ‘infrastructure cess’.
- The FCC voided all dependent rules, notifications, assessments and recovery measures and ordered that no demand, surcharge or penalty based solely on those provincial charges be enforced.
- Administratively, the ruling requires verification and discharge of securities posted for the invalid charges and will force customs authorities and the FBR to change collection practices for goods crossing provincial or international frontiers.
- Practically, provinces may still lawfully tax goods made and consumed entirely inside their borders but face near‑term revenue and trade impacts because levies tied to imports, exports or interprovincial movement fall within the federal legislative list; the KP law’s 2024 amendment that raised the cess to 2% was directly engaged in the litigation.