Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Ex-United Coach Calls McTominay Sale ‘One of Football’s Biggest Mistakes’

Benni McCarthy’s criticism highlights clubwide regret, exposing flaws in United’s scouting following McTominay’s rise.

Image
Image

Overview

  • Benni McCarthy said everyone at Manchester United now regrets letting academy graduate Scott McTominay join Napoli last summer.
  • The £25.7 million transfer was structured to meet profit and sustainability rules, counting as pure profit and including a 10 percent sell-on clause.
  • McTominay scored 12 Serie A goals, provided six assists and was named Player of the Season as Napoli secured the Scudetto.
  • McCarthy revealed that United’s scouting department vetoed his proposal to sign Cody Gakpo, illustrating deeper recruitment disagreements.
  • His public denunciation has renewed scrutiny of United’s balance between financial compliance and long-term squad building.