Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Evidence Suppression Hearing Opens in Mangione Case as Judge Weighs Backpack and Statements

The outcome could decide the fate of key evidence with consequences for the parallel federal case.

Overview

  • The multi-day Mapp and Huntley hearings began Monday before Judge Gregory Carro, with prosecutors expected to call more than 20 witnesses including officers involved in the Altoona arrest.
  • Prosecutors played surveillance of the Manhattan shooting and video of the McDonald’s arrest, while the defense pointed to questioning captured on camera before Miranda warnings.
  • Defense lawyers moved to suppress items allegedly taken from a backpack—among them a handgun, a silencer, electronics, fake IDs and a red notebook—arguing the search was conducted without a warrant.
  • The Manhattan District Attorney’s Office opposes suppression and says the search was lawful and the evidence speaks to motive and a possible murder weapon.
  • Terrorism-related state counts were dismissed in September, trial dates remain unset in both courts, and federal prosecutors continue to seek the death penalty.