Overview

• Bill Barnwell outlined a hypothetical deal linking the Cardinals, Giants and Chargers, with Johnston headed to Arizona and Neal to Los Angeles.
• Barnwell’s terms include the Giants receiving a 2027 seventh-round pick from the Chargers and the Chargers receiving a 2026 fifth-round pick from the Cardinals.
• Commentary highlights Johnston’s preseason concussion and ongoing drop issues, with a projected slot role in Arizona competing with Greg Dortch to support Kyler Murray.
• Neal is characterized as underperforming and inexpensive after the Giants declined his fifth-year option, leaving about $1.1 million owed this season.
• Analysts question the feasibility and value of the three-way construct, noting such deals are rare and arguing the Giants’ proposed return looks insufficient, with no actual trade in place as roster cuts near.