Eric André Reflects on Turning Down Kieran Culkin’s Oscar-Winning Role in 'A Real Pain'

The comedian revealed he declined the part due to personal discomfort, as Kieran Culkin's acclaimed performance continues to draw attention.

Eric André disclosed that Jesse Eisenberg offered him the role of Benji Kaplan in 'A Real Pain,' which Kieran Culkin later played to Oscar-winning acclaim.
André turned down the role, citing discomfort with the film's tone and the emotional weight of its Holocaust-focused narrative.
Kieran Culkin's portrayal of Benji earned him the 2025 Oscar for Best Supporting Actor, along with other major awards like the SAG and Independent Spirit Awards.
Culkin initially considered dropping out of the film but was persuaded to stay by producer Emma Stone, who also advised Eisenberg against playing the role himself.
André expressed regret over his decision, acknowledging the rarity of such opportunities and reflecting on the career impact of passing on the role.