Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Ed Gein Netflix Series Faces Accuracy Scrutiny as Expert Questions Diagnosis and Next Season Begins Filming

Fresh expert analysis, paired with a 1957 schizophrenia diagnosis, reframes the show’s mental-health lens.

Overview

  • Netflix released the eight-part Monster: The Ed Gein Story on Oct. 3 starring Charlie Hunnam, and it quickly hit the platform’s top spot as criticism over graphic content intensified.
  • A 1957 psychiatric evaluation documented in John Borowski’s The Ed Gein File diagnosed Gein with a “schizophrenic reaction of the chronic undifferentiated type,” and he was later found not guilty by reason of mental disease.
  • Psychiatrist Paul E. Mullen said a case like Gein’s could recur today and argued the historical schizophrenia label likely would not meet current diagnostic criteria, citing isolation and fixation on death as warning signs.
  • Fact-checkers report the series interweaves fiction with history, with certain violent incidents depicted on screen unsupported by the historical record.
  • Netflix says cameras are rolling on season 4 centered on Lizzie Borden, with Hunnam set to return in a different role.