Early Reviews Criticize Robert De Niro's Dual Role in 'The Alto Knights'
The Mafia-themed film, set for release on March 21, 2025, faces negative reception for its disjointed narrative and underwhelming execution, despite standout supporting performances.
- Robert De Niro portrays both Frank Costello and Vito Genovese in the film, but critics found his dual performance lacking distinction and impact.
- The film, based on the real-life 1950s rivalry between two New York mob bosses, was written by Nicholas Pileggi and directed by Barry Levinson.
- Critics highlighted issues with the screenplay and direction, describing the narrative as disjointed and emotionally flat.
- Supporting actors Kathrine Narducci and Cosmo Jarvis received praise for their compelling performances, standing out in an otherwise criticized cast.
- The highly anticipated diner confrontation between the two De Niro characters was widely regarded as lacking dramatic tension and failing to deliver.
Newsweek 
Boston Globe 
CNN 
The Independent 
Chicago Sun Times 
Collider 
The Telegraph 
Datebook | SF Arts & Entertainment 
SlashFilm 
The Daily Beast 