Particle.news

Download on the App Store

DHS Retains Controversial “American Progress” Post Despite Artists’ Lawsuits

The department’s refusal to remove the 1872 frontier painting has prompted intensified legal and ethical challenges over coded white supremacist messaging

Image

Overview

  • DHS continues to feature John Gast’s “American Progress” on its official social media channels with the caption “A Heritage to be proud of, a Homeland worth Defending,” even after artists demanded its removal.
  • Morgan Weistling and the Thomas Kinkade Family Foundation have threatened lawsuits over unauthorized use of their works, accusing DHS of exploiting nostalgic art to promote division and xenophobia.
  • Observers and legal experts allege the captions embed white supremacist dog whistles through unusual capitalization and a 14-word count that echo “HH” and the “14 Words” malevolent creed.
  • The Department of Homeland Security has defended its art campaign in a formal statement, asserting it “honors artwork that celebrates America’s heritage and history” and refusing to take down any contested images.
  • Critics warn that this high-volume, provocative art strategy under Secretary Kristi Noem marks a stark departure from the agency’s previous neutral messaging toward coded nationalist propaganda.