Overview
- New analyses by UI designers Niki and Nikita Prokopov, amplified on January 6 by tech outlets, fault Tahoe for adding icons to nearly every menu item.
- The critiques argue that universal icon placement undercuts visual scanning, noting that if every command has an icon, none stands out to guide the eye.
- Reviewers document inconsistent symbolism across apps, with different icons used for the same action and identical icons reused for unrelated functions.
- Legibility concerns center on tiny roughly 12×12 pixel glyphs rendered as vector symbols, which critics say blur and lose meaningful detail at normal sizes.
- Reactions vary as shortcut-heavy users report little disruption, and as of the latest coverage there is no reported response or fix from Apple.