Overview
- Special Judge Dig Vinay Singh set aside the April 1 order of ACJM Vaibhav Chaurasia that had sought a renewed probe into an alleged February 23, 2020 incident in Kardampuri.
- The court found a serious jurisdictional error, noting that once cognisance was taken in FIR No. 59/2020, the magistrate could not direct “further investigation” and any order affecting liberty had to be unambiguous.
- It said the magistrate conflated reinvestigation with further investigation and made unwarranted comments on issues already being tried in the larger conspiracy case under UAPA.
- The complaint by Mohammad Ilyas alleged Mishra and others blocked a road and vandalised vendors’ carts, but the sessions court said the application did not clearly disclose a cognisable offence and contained inconsistencies.
- With the order quashed and an earlier stay lifted, there is no direction to register a new FIR or reopen inquiry, though the complainant can approach the High Court while the broader FIR No. 59/2020 trial continues.