Overview
- At a Crain’s forum, the independent mayoral candidate proposed demolishing and rebuilding on Rikers, offering free express buses and turning planned borough jail sites into housing and commercial projects.
- The plan conflicts with a 2019 City Council mandate to shutter Rikers, would require legislative reversal, and runs up against more than $15 billion already committed to borough-jail contracts.
- A March report from the Independent Rikers Commission found rebuilding on the island would likely take longer and cost 8%–15% more due to environmental, access and operational constraints.
- Rikers remains under a federal monitor in the Nunez case, with courts considering receivership after detainee deaths and ongoing safety failures as the jail population hovers near 7,000.
- Reaction was swift: Council leadership labeled the idea a political ploy, Democrat Zohran Mamdani reaffirmed support for borough jails, and Republican Curtis Sliwa blasted Cuomo’s reversal despite backing improvements on Rikers.