Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Critics Weigh In on 'The Dutchman,' Andre Gaines’s Meta Reimagining of Baraka

Early reviews highlight André Holland’s performance, with concerns about the film’s blunt execution.

Overview

  • Andre Gaines makes his first fiction feature by adapting Amiri Baraka’s play into a present-day, tonally bold film.
  • The story expands beyond the subway to locations such as an apartment and a Harlem fundraiser, broadening the play’s once-contained scope.
  • A mystical, meta layer features Stephen McKinley Henderson as a guiding figure named Dr. Amiri and includes on-screen nods to the 1966 film version.
  • The principal cast includes André Holland, Kate Mara, Zazie Beetz, Stephen McKinley Henderson and Aldis Hodge, with Holland receiving standout praise.
  • Reviewers cite ambition and strong performances but fault heavy-handed choices, messy logic and a limited engagement with Black women’s perspectives, noting the film assumes familiarity with the source material.