Overview
- Superior Court Justice Éric Dufour dismissed Bloc Québécois candidate Nathalie Sinclair-Desgagné’s challenge to the April Terrebonne result.
- The ruling held that the postal code mix-up on Elections Canada materials was an inadvertent administrative error, not an electoral irregularity under federal law.
- Dufour warned that treating administrative mistakes as irregularities would invite numerous contests and said annulments are reserved for the most serious cases.
- Evidence showed an election employee mistakenly printed his own postal code on at least 40 special-ballot envelopes, leading one Bloc voter to have her ballot returned.
- The result stands with Liberal Tatiana Auguste declared the winner after a May 10 judicial recount set the tally at 23,352 to 23,351, as Liberals govern in a minority and the Bloc reviews the decision.