Overview
- Challengers AfriForum, the Democratic Alliance and the Institute of Race Relations argued in the Western Cape High Court on Tuesday and Wednesday that sections 12(3) and 19(2)/(3) unlawfully permit expropriation without compensation and must be struck down or sent back to Parliament.
- Legal teams for the challengers said the phrase “including, but not limited to” and listed grounds for nil compensation let administrators award nothing and thereby upend the Constitution’s requirement for a just and equitable payment.
- The State Attorney defended the Act, telling the court that section 25 must be read in context and that any limit on property rights can be justified under section 36 of the Constitution as a lawful limitation.
- Amici and challengers warned that leaving key compensation decisions to administrators rather than courts risks irreversible undercompensation even if judicial review comes later, because the property will already have been taken.
- A judgment could force Parliament to revise the law, prompt appeals to higher courts and shape how government balances accelerated land reform with legal protection of owners and investor confidence.