Overview
- On Wednesday, Nov. 18, outgoing Sen. John Cornyn said he would not return the blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, effectively stopping the nomination from moving to a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing.
- Gaiser, who leads the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel and already cleared an FBI background check for his DOJ role, did not appear at the scheduled committee hearing after Cornyn’s move.
- Cornyn told reporters he objects because Gaiser is not a Texan, lacks trial experience, and was not vetted by Texas’s bipartisan Federal Judicial Evaluation Committee, and he has pushed Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey as an alternative.
- The White House has asked Cornyn for information on Fahey, the Justice Department criticized Cornyn’s decision as political obstruction, and Sen. Ted Cruz warned there is too little time to get a different nominee confirmed before Democrats assume Senate control.
- The dispute exposes a crack in GOP ranks — including a loud clash between Cornyn and Cruz on the Senate floor — and underscores how the blue-slip custom and the impending Jan. 3, 2027, transfer of Senate majority could decide who fills the lifetime judgeship.