Particle.news

Confidential Study Recommends Distance‑Based Car Toll to Stabilize Autobahn Finances

PD finds Verkehrsminister Steffen Bilger’s borrowing plan will likely leave Autobahn GmbH running losses with revenue pressure rising before the federal infrastructure fund ends in 2037.

Overview

  • A government‑commissioned, confidential PD study reviewed multiple financing options and ranks a combined distance‑based car toll (Pkw‑Maut) plus the truck toll (Lkw‑Maut) as the strongest way to secure Autobahn GmbH funding through 2056.
  • The study says Bilger’s proposal to let Autobahn GmbH borrow and receive part of Lkw‑Maut revenue improves the outlook but still leaves the company prone to continuous losses and creates significant pressure to raise income by early 2034.
  • PD scored the scenarios by total economic utility: status quo 56.6%, Bilger’s reform 65.8%, full Lkw‑Maut 77.4% and combined Pkw+Lkw‑Maut 79.9%, with the combined model offering the greatest independence from annual federal budget transfers.
  • The report flags major legal risks because a 2019 European Court of Justice ruling struck down an earlier German car toll for discriminating against foreign drivers, meaning any new Pkw‑Maut would need careful design to survive lawsuits.
  • If implemented, a distance‑based car toll would directly affect drivers’ costs—model examples show low per‑kilometre rates can still mean hundreds of euros a year for frequent Autobahn users—and the study warns volatility in toll revenue and the 2037 expiry of the special infrastructure fund increase urgency for a durable solution.