Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Commerce Department Pushes Back on Trump’s Plan to Exclude Undocumented Immigrants From Census

Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said constitutional requirements obligate counting every person, making any plan to exclude undocumented immigrants from a mid-decade census contingent on congressional approval.

Is Donald Trump's New Census Constitutional?
No Kings Protest against the policies of Pres. Donald Trump in McAllen on June 14, 2025.
Image

Overview

  • On Aug. 7, President Trump directed the Department of Commerce to start work on a mid-decade census that would omit undocumented immigrants from the population count.
  • Howard Lutnick told Census Bureau staff that federal law and the 14th Amendment require the enumeration of every person in the United States regardless of legal status.
  • Lutnick said an off-cycle census intended for congressional reapportionment and excluding noncitizens could not move forward without explicit authorization and funding from Congress.
  • Constitutional scholars have warned that removing undocumented residents from apportionment counts would violate the Enumeration Clause and face immediate legal challenges.
  • Officials estimate a mid-decade census would cost roughly $15 billion and involve substantial logistical and operational hurdles before it could be executed.