Overview
- A machine and manual recount left Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold deadlocked at 3,162 votes each, triggering a formal tiebreak under local rules.
- Election officials held a public best-of-three coin toss on Nov. 13, 2026, and Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland used the office challenge coin to conduct the flips.
- Each candidate had the right to call the first two tosses under the procedure, and Lagner won two straight flips to take the contest without a third toss.
- Officials opened a late-arriving overseas ballot and found the Atlantic Beach race left blank, so it did not change the tie before the tiebreaker.
- County officials said this was only the second Duval County race decided by lot, a reminder that Florida law permits random tiebreakers and that every single local vote can be decisive.