Particle.news

Coin Toss Decides Atlantic Beach City Commission Race

The result underscores that Florida law allows exact election ties to be settled by chance and it finalizes who will fill Seat 4.

Overview

  • A machine and manual recount left Jennifer Lagner and Lisa Herrold deadlocked at 3,162 votes each, triggering a formal tiebreak under local rules.
  • Election officials held a public best-of-three coin toss on Nov. 13, 2026, and Duval County Supervisor of Elections Jerry Holland used the office challenge coin to conduct the flips.
  • Each candidate had the right to call the first two tosses under the procedure, and Lagner won two straight flips to take the contest without a third toss.
  • Officials opened a late-arriving overseas ballot and found the Atlantic Beach race left blank, so it did not change the tie before the tiebreaker.
  • County officials said this was only the second Duval County race decided by lot, a reminder that Florida law permits random tiebreakers and that every single local vote can be decisive.