Particle.news

Chidambaram Rejects One Nation One Election Bill

His testimony to the Joint Parliamentary Committee argues the amendment breaches the Constitution’s basic structure and disputes claims that a 2029 rollout is legally possible

Overview

  • Senior Congress leader P. Chidambaram told the 31‑member Joint Parliamentary Committee that the Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill and the Union Territories Laws (Amendment) Bill are unconstitutional because they would curtail five‑year legislative terms.
  • Chidambaram argued the draft’s ‘appointed date’ language allows that date only after a general election, which he says makes a lawful 2029 synchronisation impossible and directly contradicts the JPC chairman’s public timeline.
  • JPC chair P.P. Chaudhary has said the bills could allow a 2029 start if Parliament approves the amendment by 2028 and state governments voluntarily agree to dissolve or align their assemblies, leaving practical rollout dependent on state choices.
  • Passage would require a two‑thirds majority in Parliament and the bills would impose a one‑time shortening of some state assembly terms to match the Lok Sabha, with media estimates showing many states could lose roughly one to three years of their current terms.
  • The committee is still taking evidence from experts, Padma awardees and policy institutes and will finalise recommendations and possible redrafting before submitting its report to Parliament in the winter session.