Particle.news

168 Zeros in Basque Euskera and 4.18 Maths Average in Catalonia Expose PAU Oversight Failures

Regional review processes have changed many student marks, prompting ministers to demand tribunal transparency and clearer correction rules.

Overview

  • Basque authorities disclosed that 168 students received a zero in the Euskera PAU, with 108 of those zeros concentrated in tribunals 11 and 12 and 79 graded by a single evaluator, a distribution the education minister called statistically atypical.
  • The rector of Euskal Herriko Unibertsitatea acknowledged that correctors can infer students’ schools despite coded IDs, a factor the Basque education minister says heightens the risk of biased outcomes and justifies publishing tribunal memberships.
  • EHU processed 4,223 review requests and rechecked 8,127 exams; most reviews kept or raised marks but about 5.5 percent of reviewed cases fell, leaving roughly 230 students with lower final PAU scores and altered university access prospects.
  • The Catalan results published Tuesday showed the scientific/technological Mathematics average plunged to 4.18, the lowest in at least a decade, triggering hundreds of student complaints, parliamentary questions, and a formal review window ahead of final scores in early July.
  • The incidents have pushed both regional governments to seek procedural reforms such as redistributing students across tribunals, clearer internal rules for corrections and rapid interinstitutional alerts, a change that could affect how future PAU exams are designed and graded.