Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Cat Deeley Criticized Over 'Normal Lives' Remark in Jesy Nelson SMA Discussion

Advocates called the phrase inappropriate, highlighting the need for disabled voices in such discussions.

Overview

  • On ITV’s This Morning, Deeley said screening at birth could enable treatment so that “the children can live normal lives,” drawing objections to her wording.
  • Disabled journalist Frances Ryan and presenter Sophie Morgan said the phrasing was inappropriate and urged broadcasters to put more disabled people on and behind the camera.
  • Jesy Nelson has used her twins’ SMA Type 1 diagnosis to push for newborn screening, noting the test is used in more than 40 countries and was cited as costing 36p per baby.
  • Nelson’s comments echoed wider policy moves, with Scotland planning to introduce SMA screening in the spring and the UK National Screening Committee commissioning a reassessment.
  • Health Secretary Wes Streeting said Nelson was right to challenge diagnostic delays and pledged to examine screening alongside better use of genomic medicine.