Overview

• Jonathan Odenthal, 31, was arraigned on a second-degree murder charge in the killing of Cindy Diaz and pleaded not guilty before being remanded, with a return date set for Nov. 13, 2025.
• Diaz, 48, was struck in the chest and arm near Boston Road and East Tremont Avenue on Jan. 6, 2017, as she walked home with food for her four children and later died at Saint Barnabas Hospital.
• Police say Diaz was not the intended target; a teen male was also wounded in the shooting and survived.
• Investigators connected Odenthal to the case while he was in federal custody in West Virginia, though authorities have not publicly detailed the steps or evidence behind the link.
• The long-unsolved killing drew a $20,000 reward and family calls for better lighting and cameras, and the case now moves forward in Bronx court.