Overview
- The Oct. 16 encounter began after Santiago Cairo called 911, armed himself, and confronted a 14-year-old he believed was part of a break-in outside his home.
- Arrest records say Cairo kept his gun in a low-ready position, while the teen told investigators the weapon was pointed and that he was ordered to his knees and grabbed by the shoulder.
- Detectives concluded there was no attempted burglary, and records note Cairo acknowledged he "went too far."
- Cairo was arrested on aggravated-assault-with-a-firearm charges, released on a $10,000 bond, has pleaded not guilty, and has a court date next month.
- A neighbor defended Cairo by citing recent car break-ins, and a criminal defense attorney said the case will hinge on whether his display of the firearm was a reasonable response.