Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Bishop Marvin Winans Criticized After Video Shows Rebuke Over $1,200 Donation

The moment came during a fundraising push for Perfecting Church’s long-delayed building project, raising questions about pledge enforcement.

Overview

  • The attendee-recorded clip was first posted to Facebook on Oct. 19 before circulating widely on Instagram, Threads and X.
  • In the video, Winans tells a woman, “That’s only $1,200,” and later replies to her offer to bring the remaining $800 later, “Well, that ain’t what I asked you to do.”
  • The exchange occurred during a “Day of Giving” linked to efforts to complete the church’s 7 Mile and Woodward complex, a project launched in 2002 and complicated by delays and a 2023 city dispute settlement.
  • Online reaction was largely critical, though some congregants defended enforcing pledges; as of Oct. 21, neither Winans nor Perfecting Church had issued a public statement.
  • Some attendees pointed to confusion over his “$1,000 plus 1” phrasing, with interpretations ranging from $1,001 to $2,000, underscoring concerns about clarity and tone during the appeal.