Particle.news

Big Tech Threatens to Pull Encrypted Services Over Canada’s Bill C-22

Senators are reviewing a bill that would let the public safety minister issue secret technical orders requiring providers to build access capabilities subject to review by the Intelligence Commissioner.

Overview

  • Tech firms including Meta, Signal and Tailscale told the Senate national security committee that they would refuse or consider withdrawing end-to-end encrypted services if ministerial orders under Bill C-22 forced them to weaken encryption, testimony that intensified pressure on senators during hearings on Monday.
  • The House-passed bill would let the public safety minister issue confidential orders requiring electronic service providers to develop technical capabilities for lawful access and could force some providers to retain connection metadata for up to six months.
  • Ottawa has added limits that bar compelling providers to decrypt customer-encrypted data unless the provider supplied the encryption and holds the keys and says orders will be reviewed by the Intelligence Commissioner, but critics say the protections are vague and leave critical encryption layers exposed.
  • Privacy regulators, independent experts and international bodies warn the bill risks creating systemic vulnerabilities that hostile actors or cybercriminals could exploit, and they have urged clearer safeguards, narrower definitions and independent technical review powers.
  • If senators do not adopt targeted amendments, the likely outcomes include reduced availability of secure services in Canada, relocation or rebranding of Canadian tech offerings, and higher cyber risk from newly created metadata stores that attackers could target.