Particle.news
Download on the App Store

Belichick Reportedly Misses First-Ballot Hall of Fame by One Vote, Intensifying Scrutiny of Process

A revised, capped ballot with secret voting prompted questions about how a near‑consensus résumé fell short.

Overview

  • Multiple outlets report Bill Belichick fell short of the 40 votes needed for first-ballot induction, with one veteran selector citing 39, while the Hall has not released an official tally ahead of the Feb. 5 announcement.
  • Selectors Mike Chappell and Vahe Gregorian publicly said they used their three allotted votes on other finalists, including Robert Kraft and senior candidates, highlighting incentives created by the three-of-five format.
  • Deliberations included references to Spygate and Deflategate, and reporting alleged Bill Polian suggested Belichick should wait a year; Polian has denied swaying colleagues and said he voted for Belichick, with The Athletic reporting the Hall confirmed his yes vote.
  • Gary Myers said Belichick told him he will not comment until after this year's class is announced, though ESPN reported he privately expressed disappointment upon learning the result.
  • Reaction from across the sport condemned the outcome, with Tom Brady and Robert Kraft defending Belichick's candidacy and commentators urging the Hall to review procedures and transparency.