Overview

• The Union of B.C. Indian Chiefs praised the B.C. Supreme Court decision as a monumental affirmation of Cowichan title and fishing rights in Richmond.
• Chief Don Tom said the case is not about seizing private homes and warned that portraying it as a threat unfairly scapegoats First Nations.
• The court found Cowichan established Aboriginal title to part of Lulu Island and foreshore, deeming titles held by Canada and the City of Richmond defective and invalid.
• The provincial government said it will appeal and cautioned about significant unintended consequences for private property rights, and the Musqueam First Nation also opposed the case.
• The ruling states the province has a duty to negotiate the reconciliation of private ownership with Cowichan’s Aboriginal title, and Grand Chief Stewart Phillip urged the Crown to engage rather than delay.