Overview
- Baroness Hilary Cass told MPs she can no longer back the draft bill, warning on Monday that it risks "serious unintended consequences" and could have "chilling effects" on clinicians who work with gender-questioning young people.
- Labour's draft Conversion Practices Bill would criminalise 'abusive' attempts to change sexual orientation or gender identity in England and Wales and carry penalties of up to five years in prison and unlimited fines for offenders.
- Critics say the draft uses broad phrases such as 'economic pressure' and 'psychological or emotional pressure' that could be read to catch routine parental decisions or clinical discussion, and they note Labour removed explicit parental carve-outs present in an earlier Conservative draft.
- Some clinicians who gave evidence to the committee said they have not seen the types of abusive conversion practices the bill targets, raising questions about how common those practices are and whether a broad criminal offence is needed.
- The bill remains under pre-legislative scrutiny and ministers say the committee process will be used to refine definitions and safeguards, with outcomes likely to affect clinicians' practice, parents' behaviour and the timetable for introducing a final law.