Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie Faces Criticism for Opposing Harsher Penalties to Deter Crime

Despite evidence suggesting harsher penalties can reduce crime, Heastie remains unconvinced, sparking debate over New York's approach to public safety.

• Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie's stance against increasing penalties for crimes, including violent retail theft, has ignited controversy in New York.
• Governor Hochul's efforts to implement harsher penalties for criminals are hindered by Heastie's opposition, based on his skepticism of deterrence.
• Studies cited include California's 'three-strikes' law and the impact of incarceration for failing to pay fines, both suggesting penalties can deter crime.
• Critics argue Heastie's focus on deterrence overlooks the importance of incapacitation in preventing crime by keeping chronic offenders off the streets.
• The debate intensifies as New York faces rising crime rates, including a significant increase in retail thefts, amid calls for stronger law enforcement measures.

3 Articles

New York Post New York Post Manhattan Institute