Particle.news

Download on the App Store

ASI Requests Revision of Keeladi Excavation Report Over Chronology Disputes

The Archaeological Survey of India has asked Amarnath Ramakrishna to revise his findings, citing the need for clearer dating justifications and improved documentation.

The ninth phase of excavation at Keeladi site in 2023. (HT PHOTO)
Image
Image

Overview

  • The ASI has directed archaeologist Amarnath Ramakrishna to resubmit his 982-page report on the Keeladi excavations with corrections recommended by two expert reviewers.
  • Key revisions include clearer nomenclature for cultural periods, stronger justification for the proposed 8th century BCE timeline, and enhanced documentation such as stratigraphic maps and trench layouts.
  • The ASI has questioned the chronology of Keeladi’s earliest period, suggesting it should be dated no earlier than pre-300 BCE based on current knowledge.
  • Ramakrishna’s earlier findings, based on AMS-dated artefacts, had proposed a timeline extending back to the 8th century BCE, sparking debates over Tamil Nadu’s ancient urban heritage.
  • The ASI’s intervention follows a two-year delay in peer review and has reignited concerns over political bias in archaeological narratives, as Tamil Nadu prepares for the eleventh excavation phase in June.