Particle.news
Download on the App Store

As 'After the Hunt' Widens to U.S. Theaters, Reviews Split on Roberts-Led Campus Thriller

Recent critiques praise the performances and craft yet fault Nora Garrett’s debut script for muddled pacing, unclear politics and limited engagement with the issues it raises.

Overview

  • Set at Yale, the drama follows professor Alma (Julia Roberts) as her protégé (Ayo Edebiri) accuses a colleague (Andrew Garfield) of sexual assault, thrusting Alma into an ethical and professional dilemma.
  • The film continues its rollout after Venice, NYFF and LFF, expanding to more U.S. theaters around Oct. 17 following select engagements earlier in the month.
  • Critics broadly commend Roberts and Edebiri, with some noting Michael Stuhlbarg’s support, but many find the narrative repetitive or underdeveloped and point to perceived generational bias.
  • Reviews highlight Malik Hassan Sayeed’s cinematography and a Trent Reznor–Atticus Ross score, though several outlets flag abrasive sound mixing and an overbearing audio balance.
  • Guadagnino and the cast frame the movie as intentionally ambiguous on questions of power, privilege and mentorship, even as festival-era controversy and an awards-season push keep it in the spotlight.