Overview
- Judges in La Plata and the national commercial court issued decisions Nov. 19–20, 2026 that require companies and insurers to pay substantial indemnities in three separate theft cases.
- A La Plata civil court ordered retail operators and related firms to pay $7,696,557.98 plus US$2,199 and interest after a laptop and other items were stolen from a truck parked at a home‑center, finding free customer parking is part of the commercial service and faulting defendants for not producing internal footage.
- A second La Plata court rejected an insurer’s fraud allegation in a May 13, 2024 Volkswagen Vento theft, ruled the insurer must pay the vehicle’s updated value and awarded $8 million for moral and punitive damages with a ten‑day payment deadline once the sentence is final.
- The Cámara Comercial (Sala D) confirmed a $2,335,000 award for a motorcycle stolen in October 2022 after concluding the policy did not clearly exclude coverage for lack of a steering lock and the insurer answered outside the legal deadline.
- All three rulings apply the Civil and Commercial Code and the Consumer Defense Law to update values, add interest and non‑pecuniary and punitive damages, and they underscore that missed insurer deadlines or failure to produce evidence can shift liability to companies and insurers, a development likely to affect contract wording and claims handling.