Overview

• Rosanna Kinsinger, 28, was found dead in her Rutland, Ohio, home on March 13 alongside her goat, prompting a murder investigation.
• Samuel Hochstetler, 18, who lived across the street from Kinsinger, was arrested on May 5 and charged with her murder.
• Authorities identified Hochstetler as a suspect after serving search warrants, conducting interviews, and processing evidence from the crime scene.
• Preliminary autopsy results from the Montgomery County Coroner’s Office were inconclusive, leaving unanswered questions about Kinsinger’s death.
• The case has deeply unsettled the local Amish community, known for its privacy and low crime rates, as legal proceedings move forward.