Particle.news

Download on the App Store

Americana Opens in Theaters With Strong Cast but Divides Critics on Originality

Praised for Sydney Sweeney’s standout performance, the film faces criticism over its derivative neo-western style.

Overview

  • Americana marks Tony Tost’s feature directorial debut after premiering at SXSW in 2023 and spending two years in festival circuits before its wide release.
  • The neo-western crime thriller centers on South Dakota locals vying for a rare Lakota ghost shirt that drives intersecting heist and revenge storylines.
  • Ensemble performances from Halsey, Paul Walter Hauser, Simon Rex, Eric Dane and Zahn McClarnon support Sydney Sweeney’s breakout lead role as diner waitress Penny Jo.
  • Critics commend the film’s chaptered, non-linear structure and polished production values even as they note its heavy debt to B-movie influences like Quentin Tarantino and the Coen Brothers.
  • Several reviewers raise concerns that the film’s portrayal of Indigenous characters and its treatment of the ghost shirt artifact lack cultural nuance.