Particle.news
Download on the App Store

All’s Fair’ Faces Harsh Reviews as Episode 4 Ignites Fan Theories and Keeps Viewers Tuning In

A darker turn in the weekly Hulu/Disney+ drama has intensified online chatter despite persistently low critic scores.

Overview

  • Episode 4, released Nov. 11, shifts the series into a darker storyline that ends on a cliffhanger, prompting active whodunit speculation on X and Reddit.
  • Critic reception remains broadly negative, with a low single‑digit Rotten Tomatoes score and notably scathing write‑ups from multiple outlets.
  • Early viewing remained strong after the Nov. 4 launch, with about 3.2 million global views in the first three days, the biggest Hulu Original debut in three years per Deadline.
  • Kim Kardashian mocked the reviews in an Instagram post, while director Anthony Hemingway told The Hollywood Reporter that the show won’t please everyone.
  • Season 1 runs 10 episodes on a weekly schedule, with Episode 5 set for Nov. 18 on Hulu and Disney+.