Particle.news
Download on the App Store

All’s Fair Debuts to Near-Zero Critic Scores Even as Viewers Tune In

The director urged viewers to give the weekly-rolling series time to find its footing.

Overview

  • The first three episodes premiered Nov. 4 on Hulu/Disney+, with additional episodes arriving weekly through a two-part finale on Dec. 9.
  • The show’s Rotten Tomatoes critics score is roughly 6% after an initial 0%, while Metacritic places it in the low-teens range labeled “overwhelming dislike.”
  • Reviews from The Guardian, The Times and The Hollywood Reporter cite weak writing and describe Kim Kardashian’s performance as “stiff and affectless.”
  • Audience response is more forgiving, with user scores in the 50s–60s and reports of strong streaming placement alongside vocal defenders on social media.
  • Executive producer-director Anthony Hemingway publicly defended the series, asking viewers to let it find an audience as more episodes roll out.